Hotel is absolutely gorgeous, secluded quite location, you can see and hear the ocean everywhere, it’s magnificent! You are literally living on the beach. Dinner at the Scarpetta restaurant is delicious, worthy of a Michelin star restaurant in Manhattan, their chef and the team are outstanding! Breakfast and lunch are also great, pretty much everything on the menu is superb quality! Safe to say that their people do an incredible job at the hotel. Spa is lovely, pool is large and the sauna/steam room area with diving pools of different temperatures are just a great place to relax. Gets pretty busy on weekends, but weekdays are perfect. The place is a gem and there is nothing like it in Montauk or anywhere near.

Overall, our experience at the hotel was fantastic. We spent 3 night in total, 2 in an oceanfront room and 1 in an ocean view room. The Oceanfront rooms (we stayed at the 3 story building on the east side) were absolutely fantastic. Great views of the ocean, beach access, quiet, clean and comfortable bed and room. We had a great relaxing time in this room and it was well worth the price. We had great runs and walks on the beach which is miles long ini each direction. The fitness center was clean, spacious and functional. We had some nice dinners and lunches (some good vegan and gluten free options too) at the restaurants and around the fire pit at night (Thanks Rafael - you're the best). Overall the staff at the hotel was nice, and professional and help accomodate us when necessary.

The first night we spent in an oceanview room, which was right above the main parking lot, somewhat noisy, with very limited view of the ocean. In our opinion, these room do not justify a stay at the hotel (and the price), despite all the good things above.

Amazing stuff, everyone was kind and nice. Bathhouse was great too! We had the most beautiful sunset and sunrise.

SMELL of the room!! Omg… guys you have to work on this. It smelled like a terrible motel room, we came home and the jackets and other things we had were so smelly… really shocking for the hotel like this

Great room. Spacious deck with reclining deck chairs so that you can take a nap out there with the fresh air and sea breeze. Everything was in working order and exceptionally clean. Staff was well-trained, friendly, and accommodating.

In-room bar pricing was a little crazy. $8.00 for a tiny bag of chips that I would give my kid to go to school. $8.00 at the coffee bar in the lobby. That seemed a little much, no?

The views and staff were absolutely amazing.

The decor seems a little cold and it would have been nice to see a carpet / rug in the lounges.

Great location, great amenities, once you park your car there’s really no reason to leave the property.

Very large property, lots of stairs, hills and uneven ground to traverse if your unit is not central to the main building. Also some of the stair cases were unlit, not very safe when walking at night. if you have a disability or elderly, you should definitely request an accessible unit. Long wait for property vehicle for transportation around the property.

Great property, all amenities face the sea, great staff, electric chargers complementary

I would rate sustainability efforts as a D. Still lots of plastic bottles, towels consumed, non reusable plastic glasses, etc… Gurneys can do better! Parking lots and cars take too much space on the property.

We stayed in the one bedroom apartment which works well for a family. Our two young kids love the indoor pool. And we love the bathhouse. Food is delicious.

Check in was too late at 5.30pm.

Room Location was excellent. Was able to sit in sun or shade. Glad to be very close to main building. Fire pit bar was welcoming and pleasant. Really enjoyed the newly updated furnishings. Scenery was beautiful. Wonderful dinners and breakfasts on the deck by the ocean. Staff was attentive, pleasant and helpful.

Was disappointed the spa was closed. Would have liked to be informed about exercise classes upon arrival. Desk gave us paper in envelope and arranged for brief tour. Since we had much traffic, we arrived later than expected. As a result, I didn’t read the papers until next late morning. Yes, my fault.

This place is special, this was our second time spending thanksgiving together and everything was great

The one bedroom residences, all of them should have fire place …