Our stay here was absolutely wonderful from start to finish!!! The staff was absolutely wonderful, especially Stefano! The breakfast was great and the best cappuccino we have had so far. Hotel Collegiata is so serene and relaxing. The grounds are well kept and the pool was a great way to spend the afternoon. You are about a 20 minute walk to San Gimignano which we did about twice a day and was a great way to get our exercise. You can drive as well but highly recommend the walk.

Nothing to do with our stay at Hotel Collegiata, but I highly recommend booking any trips to wineries for meals or tastings well in advance of your stay! Research restaurants outside of the city in advance and make some reservations for an authentic Tuscan dining experience.

Our stay at La Collegiata was wonderful! It’s a lovely boutique hotel reminiscent of a bygone era. It's a tranquil and peaceful oasis away from the hustle and bustle but very close to the center of San Gimignano. The rooms were comfortable and clean. The breakfast, which had so many choices, was delicious (as was lunch). The pool area was delightful, never crowded, and very peaceful. And..The staff was amazing! Everyone went out of their way to ensure we were comfortable and at our disposal for whatever we needed, and the two managers, Stefano and Maria Rosa were always on hand. They are the best staff we have ever had. We spent nine glorious days here, and I can honestly say we became friends. I was sorry to say goodbye!

We would have liked the option to have dinner at the hotel on days when we were super tired or just wanted to sit and relax. There was only one restaurant really close by and was quite good, but there were nights we would have preferred to just chill, relax and have dinner on site. However, all else was so great, this was not an issue.

The staff was very good. The hotel is so beautiful and the pool is clean. Beautiful place. Breakfast is tasty, and capuchino is included in Breakfast, also very tasty. They have outside jakuzy, which it is included in price, but from the bar, you need to pay. We dring 3 glasses of wine, 2 sendviches and 2 capuchino it was 55euro (maybe something more we took). Nevertheless everything was really good and it looks like you are in some feritale. Parking is also included in price. Reception working 24h.

The bed is too soft, but this is not too bad. Lounday it is very expensive if somebody need.

This property is absolutely beautiful! It is a quiet relaxing atmosphere and the pool an amazing, with a bar. The breakfast is unbelievable. Everything is perfect!! The staff are all so lovely and helpful! The owners are really nice. We had an amazing anniversary spent here. It’s close to everything in Tuscany. But you will definitely want to stay and enjoy this place too!! Thank you for looking after us so well!! Our room was amazing!!

Nothing. It’s beautiful.

This hotel really was gorgeous! It surpassed our expectations in terms of the setting, surroundings, style and service. The pool area and general ambience was lovely and so relaxing. Breakfast was incredible! The team and service was fantastic. We really wished we had booked a longer stay.

The only thing that could have made our stay better would have been for the hotel to provide an evening food offering, even if room-service style. On a couple of occasions we were enjoying relaxing at the hotel so much we didn’t want to have to get dressed up and go to town, so being able to have a simple dinner service at the hotel would have been ideal.

Location was excellent away from the hustle & noise in town The manager Stefano went out of his way to help us & thank goodness he was there overseeing all aspects of the property & keeping all guests happy

No tea or coffee making in room & a charge if you ordered tea or coffee during the day. No restaurant on the property so it meant driving daily to town where it was virtually impossible to find parking as there are only 4 car parks outside the walled city. No cars are allowed into San Gimignano and many tourists driving around looking for parking

The staff was incredible. Manager Stefano and his team were so accommodating,, we hated to leave. Incredible breakfast!! Pool was beautiful and very thankful it was there as weather was very hot.

Wish they served dinner and was able to walk to town.

The hotel was just incredible. Everything about it was perfect. Beautiful location, very clean and well maintained hotel. Very welcoming staff. Special mention to Steffano who always made us laugh and cooked us delicious omelettes for breakfast! Also Luliana on the front desk who was very attentive and extremely helpful. She was always polite and happy to go the extra mile. I would highly recommend this place.

I simply liked everything. I want to plan another trip with more of my family. I have owned hotel/restaurants and would live to own this. The location is gorgeous and the building historic, my perfect combination. The staff were friendly and accommodated is in every way. The scenery was more beautiful than the pictures.

The restaurant had just closed for the season which we totally understand. I would have liked to have food available through the restaurant and I don’t think I would have left the property much. Now that I’m in Florence I wish I had visited many wineries on my stay. Some were closed for season also. Next trip I’m come in sept and stay longer, to enjoy all the surroundings and restaurant.

The service and Stefano (manager), was amazing and made our stay. The swimming pool was fantastic!

There were tea or coffee making facilities in the room and therefore had to pay 5-Euros to have it brought to our room…and no restaurant on-site for dinner etc. when you didn’t feel like driving to San Gimignano (not far away), but parking is horrendous to find…