The accommodation was perfect, close to Duval Street. The hotel is very charming, has private access to the beach and a good size pool. The hotel staff is nice and helpful. The rooms are big and spacious. I liked that while staying at the pool, a staff member passes by and hands out cold water or a cold snack. Really cute.

Unfortunately more than once we had to ask for the room to be cleaned. Elevators didn't work. We were promised a $200 refund for not tidying the room. We didn't get them. The menu in the restaurant was very limited. The hotel bar closes very early. The air conditioner in the room is very noisy and above the bed which frees you up. Parking costs a lot when it's part of the hotel and on the face of it seems unnecessary to demand. It is better if they include the parking in the room rate and give the feeling that the parking is free.

The location to the tourist area of the town was convenient while at the same time offering a beach front access.

Upon Check In I encountered a faulty Air Conditioner system. Although they promptly had a repair man come up and swap the unit out- My room was uncomfortable climate wise for my first 3 hours of my visit. At what amounted to $1000 a night; that’s not a very hospitable way to greet a New Customer! Also had an incident with some very tiny ants that got attracted to some M&M’s I had bought. They were so small that I didn’t see them immediately but they apparently got me good all over my right forearm and I still have sores a week later.

own private beach full pool service: lounge chairs, umbrellas, towels, poolside bar service modern comfortable rooms with excellent air conditioning and humidity control, balcony comfortable and good views

minor issue but annoying, the direct tv service kept loosing signal like every few minutes for the entire time we were there. we complained but housewife issue I know checkins are after 4pm and we got in at 1130 so we were hoping to maybe checkin a little earlier. I know checkouts need to be cleaned but during our stay every time we went in and out of our rooms we passed housekeeping and almost every time they were leaning on the rail next to their carts talking on the phone. should think about holding them accountable to turn around times on rooms.

Excellent-the grounds, the service, the staff (everyone was sooo friendly and helpful!) the location, the room, the food. Good-the beach.

Could use improvement-the pool is very old, the elevator was broken, our bathroom sink had a very loud leak, housekeeping stopped by once during our 4 night stay. The “daily hotel charge” ($55 per day) covers all the things that should be included in the price of your stay.

The Location!!having a private beach was a major attraction The Rooms were larger than expected with a balcony

I felt the staff at the front office could be a lot more friendly doesn't hurt to serve with a smile , when you are in hospitality business for some reason they came across as "cold" !!

Excellent dinner and lunch restaurant four Marlins with great views

After requesting staff that room needed to be cleaned several times nothing happened in four days. Toilet in bathroom was dirty from day one. No effort was made to remove excess sargassum accumulated on shore of beach.

Our wait for our room was well worth it!!! Celebrating our 23rd wedding anniversary in Key West was amazing. The Reach hospitality and staff were wonderful, no complaints!! Loved our room, view and everything around us. They made our stay unforgettable. I give Laura at the front desk a 10, and the rest of the crew a 10 as well. They checked on us daily and made us feel so welcome :) We will definitely be back!!! Thank you again!!

clean, friendly staff nice beach front location

Front Marina pricing is high. considering it’s the only pool/beach side bar its expensive because they can get away with it. No beach activities which is weird because they have a private beach on the island

Location and staff are great, restaurant food was wonderful

The cleaning of the room wasn’t done properly. The cleaner used a smelly mop to clean the floor and it left a very bad smell in the room. They also neglected to clean the room on one of the days

The grounds were lovely, beautiful view, beach and pool were wonderful. Room was comfortable.

The maid service was not good. We stayed five nights and room wasn’t restocked very well. Had to ask for supplies every day including towels, coffee,water, toilet paper etc.