The Inn was so charming and welcoming. Fireside reading, family games in a breakfast room and just cozy and welcoming. Comfy communal seating throughout. There were lending libraries all through the INN and board games and foosball available. My daughter also appreciated hot cocoa and cookies before bed each night in the lobby. Although breakfast was your average continental breakfast, it was cozy welcoming and comfortable. The staff were friendly and helpful. Also appreciated that it’s the first place in 4 years I have found a bedside Bible. (Not a big deal for many but a WIN in my book) We will be making a trip back!

My only complaint was our bathroom door didn’t shut due to a warped door frame from aging, but it was manageable for my family, no issues.

This was our second stay at Colts Neck Inn, as it is conveniently located near Eagle Oaks Country Club. Colts Neck Inn is clearly a labor of love. I appreciate all of the attention to detail that the owners put in - from the cookies and coffee that are out, to the fire pit, to the board games, to all of the books available to read, to the opportunity to borrow bikes, to the inspirational signs found throughout the hotel. The Colts Neck Inn is so cute. We have stayed in a king room as well as a king suite and both were lovely. The rooms are a nice size. There is a fridge available in the rooms if needed. They even left water bottles for guests. The bathroom in the king room that we stayed in was on the older side, but it was well maintained and clean. The continental breakfast is nice, and there is a restaurant right next door. There's also plenty of parking. We hope to return!

The place was a hidden gem with many little “extra touches” surprising you at every turn. The owner has thought of the little things you would never see in a chain hotel… board games & books throughout the hotel, several separate clusters of outdoor seating with fire pits (kindling inside), 24 hr coffee & cookies, and bikes to ride!!!

The only thing I didn’t love was the air conditioners. It was plenty cold, but as with older buildings, each unit had its own unit that was loud when it cycled on and off. At some point maybe switch to the ductless units.

The location was great for my needs. The staff was very helpful, pleasant and responsive. There were little touches everywhere (like bottles of water, cookies, candies, etc) that made me feel like my stay was appreciated.

The first night, my room was hot. I couldn’t turn the heat off and I had the window AC unit on full blast, and I was still sweating. The bed wasn’t too comfortable, not sure if that was due to the mattress or the supports but it had a slight sag. The AC unit was super loud when it kicked in and startled me a couple of times, which just added to the sleep difficulty. I did get the least expensive room so it is entirely possible the upstairs rooms have better beds, etc.

This hotel felt like I was walking into a Hallmark Movie. Loved the decorations and the room was spacious, get bathroom, and could not hear the people next to us. I my complaint is the water smelled and there was coffee but could not find the hot water for tea. Their continental breakfast was great. Very clean! I will book again next year!

The room lost power for two hours in the middle of the night, the alarm clock was only for show but that is ok, and the bath water smelled. Things the hotel really could not control.

No complaints. Clean room , historic inn. Was great for what we needed. Provided sufficient towels and soap. Water bottles . Coffee was always available in lobby ( Keurig ). Fridge in family room which is what we had. Room was clean. Beds comfortable. Breakfast quite adequate and sufficient-bagels, toast , yogurts, cereals, coffee,tea and fruit . Only complaint is the scent of whatever cleaner was used in the room was a bit overpowering and we could still smell it on our clothes when we reached home.

Just the overpowering cleaner smell as stated above . Mayb tone it down a bit. Not a dealbreaker but for some family members it was too much .

I loved how it felt very inviting and warm. It almost was like we were in a Hallmark movie! The employees were really nice, and it definitely seems like they keep up on the maintenance regularly. Very clean and great water pressure.

The room was very warm throughout the night, even though we put our air conditioner down to 62. I believe it’s because there was no fan to circulate the air. Also, the bed was not comfortable, so I was up every hour because of that and how brought it was in the room. They need window darkening curtains.

Very pleasant staff, receptionist helped me several times, hotel is beautiful, older style but everything was very clean and beautiful and quiet. We will be back again and again.

Wish there was a bigger spread for breakfast, maybe eggs/sausage. Also people were ontop of each other at breakfast, it's always a little awkward bc we are strangers. Maybe have another counter with more items. Everyone tended to end up by the bagels. But food was good and breakfast area was clean, just a little crowded. Still rate the hotel a 10 for our stay.

The welcoming staff was exceptional. We were greeted on the front step by a little white cat named Pearl. There were lots of nice little touches like the fresh flowers throughout the public spaces and in the room. There were even towel animals. There were Madeline’s and palmettos available in the lobby. Breakfast was simple but good. It was easy to find. There were quiet hours. Rooms were spacious and comfortable.

The walls were quite thin so we could hear music and tv from the adjoining room.

We were apprehensive booking a hotel in the Jersey shore area because so many places are run down. And reviews are often mixed. The Colts Neck Inn however, exceeded our expectations. The room was clean and up to date; there was even a fresh rose on the night table! Staff was friendly. And we liked the little extras (free bicycles, board games, breakfast).

A bit too much of a strong cleaning product smell in the room. Also, the AC unit was low and right next to the bed. So the person next to the AC was very cold but those at the second bed were not getting enough cool air.