The Baker House 1650

The property is splendid, I can't imagine how beautiful it must be in the spring. The room (Fifthian) was very cute and comfy, everything was super clean, breakfast was very good, spa is so special and beautiful, and the staff was adorable. I wish I could have stayed longer.

Everything was absolutely perfect and the rate was fair (being during the week in winter), I am not sure I would be able to come during the high season due to the price, unfortunately! We were facing the garden so the room was quiet.

Immaculate grounds and well maintained buildings. Loved the carriage house and it's upscale decor/design.

Bed in the carriage house room was hard and both my and my wife's back hurt in the mornings. They hosted a private yoga event one morning and we couldn't use the pool and lounge chairs. We thought a notice about this event slid under the door the night before, for example would have been nice. Breakfast wait staff needs to be on same page and ask if you want cream with your coffee as we had to wait on two occasions until much after the coffee was brought to the table.

One of the most romantic hotels I have stayed in! The public rooms, the outdoor terrace for breakfast (superb!), the carriage house, the grounds-gorgeous. And the staff, ALL of them, where delightful and extremely helpful. If you are looking for an alternative to spare/modern/ikea like furnishings…this is the place. Can’t wait to go back. Will opt for next room size up however…

Room size was a bit tight.

A wonderful time with the family. There are no traditional hotels in East Hampton, so the Baker House is a great choice as an upscale B&B. The house a grounds are immaculate. Staff was awesome. We are a black family of four. The accommodations and service for us were great from start to finish. My daughter left an ear ring and they called to let us know and sent it to my home free of charge. This is a well-deserved perfect rating.

Breakfast, location, decorations, staff. Awesome house hotel to stay in the hamptons; cozy environment, personalized treatment and beautiful decoration. Breakfast is amazing, location is great and beautiful house. We were also told they have beach passes for 5 beaches but didn't use them because were in the winter and snow. Would definitely come back!

Cleaning room hours should include afternoon (we were told they only clean until 12pm) . Quality of the pillows (too soft

The Baker House was a beautiful oasis in the heart of East Hampton! The grounds were peaceful and perfectly maintained. The pools were heated so as to enjoy on the 70 degree days. The House contained all its original charm and architecture with beautiful decor. The staff was amazing! Everyone from the waitstaff to housekeeping was friendly and did a flawless job. And the Spa is not to be missed! As a massage therapist and aesthetician myself, the quality of the technicians was superior. The owner is present and talks with her guests and cares about not only the quality of their stay but who we were as individuals. I needed peace and quiet and that was exactly what I got. I could go on and on. I have nothing but accolades for this place. Worth every penny and worth planning a longer stay.

nothing!

The only thing i would change is the mattress in my room. It feels a bit old, uneven and not supportive enough.

Breakfast was amazing. Alejandro gave us a tour of the grounds and was so pleasant, knowledgeable and accommodating. Everyone was friendly and helpful. We will definitely go back.

Nothing

The sitting areas and garden were very welcoming comforting and peaceful.

steps going up into the bathroom and deep bathtub with challenging access for elders

Great location. Beautiful setting. Breakfast excellent. Staff great. Parking passes to the beach. East Hampton shopping close.

Rooms on the main road can have traffic noise. Either bring ear plugs if light sleeper or request rooms in carriage house