Great location for breaking up our weekend walking the South Downs way. All the staff were great. We ordered dinner and it was exceptional. Really gutted that we had to get back on the trail before breakfast was served as I'd read great things about it from other reviews. We were offered a bacon sarnie, which was a nice touch. That said, missing the full breakfast gives us a good excuse to visit again in the future.

Annoyingly the cab that picked us up took us to the wrong place for the start of our day 2 walk which added a hefty amount to the fare. It was a miscommunication that can happen.

Very welcoming traditional pub with excellent menu in the restaurant. Comfortable bed and large bath with perfect plumbing, which is not always what you get in older English pub accommodation. If you want the feel of a South Downs village, this would be a great place to stay.

Breakfast was not available early enough for me but landlord did organise a prepacked sandwich so I could get away early without starving! Not anything to do with the pub, but mobile phone signal at the location was useless, virtually zero on Three and very weak on O2. WiFi worked fine as an alternative once in the building.

Jim and Julie made us feel extremely welcome as soon as we arrived, helping us with activity suggestions for the local area, and going above and beyond to make sure we were looked after. We stayed for three nights, our room was very comfortable and had everything we needed. Each morning we tried something different on the breakfast menu and everything we had was delicious and prepared with obvious care. We also ate in the pub two evenings, particularly enjoying the many fish dishes available. The staff were all equally as welcoming and we felt very comfortable relaxing downstairs in the pub when it was a bit rainy. thanks so much for making our stay so enjoyable :)

We only ended up here because our booked hotel in Chichester shut its door suddenly and cancelled our booking. It's a 15 minute drive from the city centre and all its attractions but even closer to Goodwood for the races, racetrack and walks. We chose the Star and Garter because of the enthusiastic reviews on here - and, dear readers, you couldn't have been more right! The rooms are very well equipped, especially for rooms above a pub, with a large comfortable bed, a fancy coffee machine and capsules (so often not provided), kettle, fan, extra blankets and so on. The landlords were welcoming and helpful - right down to guiding us to a car park in Chichester, where parking spaces are like gold dust (don't shoot me, we were attending a graduation ceremony and smartly dressed and it was tipping it down!) We didn't eat an evening meal as we'd pre-booked in Chichester but the pub has an attractive menu. Breakfast was excellent, with a large choice of items, well prepared. I especially liked that the pub chose sustainable and local options without making a song and dance about it - from 'give a crap' toilet paper to heritage tomatoes and super sourdough toast. Chapeau to Jim and his team!

I have absolutely nothing negative to say about the Star and Garter and - as my wife said - that is not like me at all!

We booked the Star and Garter as we were having a day at the races and found the location ideal being just a couple of miles away, a swift check in by friendly staff enabled us a quick freshen up and change of clothes as we arrived later than planned. The bar staff in the evening were equally friendly and welcoming. We made our way down for breakfast and met Jim the landlord with a relaxed introduction that instantly made us feel welcome a pleasant start to the day before enjoying a lovely cooked to order full English with plenty of tea and coffee .

We can’t think of any negative.A

A fantastic pub with rooms in a beautiful village - ideally placed for walking in the South Downs. The room was lovely, with a massive bathroom and some great touches like nice shampoo and conditioner and fresh milk in the fridge for tea and coffee. But what made this place really stand out for me was the staff - from the owner through to the bar and waiting staff, everyone was super friendly and really couldn't do enough for us. Add in a delicious dinner and a really good breakfast and you have all the ingredients for a perfect weekend.

Nothing. The only negative was that we all picked up ticks on our walk - but that's nothing to do with the pub! Worth knowing though if you are planning on doing any walking which is why I've added it to my review. Wear long trousers!

Very warm and accommodating hosts! Nothing was too much trouble and they have recommendations for the surrounding area. Bed was comfy. Food was outstanding, particularly the breakfast! Mostly locally sourced and a fantastic garden to enjoy some wine from local vineyards. Lots of amenities in the room (coffee machine, small fridge, anything you would need for a short stay) Powerful shower and all toiletries supplied.

Nothing!

From start to finish our stay at the Star and Garter was outstanding. Our room was spacious, immaculately clean and well equipped. The highlight for 0A (long haired Commanding Officer) was the huge bath. On arrival we were greeted by Harry; a courteous and helpful chap. The pub's garden area is sublime; plenty of tables for all. My lady was impressed with dinner and breakfast.....this is my fav meal of the day and I make the most of it; at the Star it is truly a well prepared feast. Both meals were delivered in in a timely manner and well presented. Whilst I didn't get the chance to say hello to Jim the Landlord, his informative email briefings on what was on tap were very helpful; for me the Star ale was delicious.

Can't find a fault with this magnificent establishment.

Secluded location. Friendly atmosphere. Quality accommodation and food.

(Not a fault as such) a large (15+ ) party arrived early evening. Up to that point - a perfectly tranquil setting. Thereafter a bit more (loud) chatter than I would have liked - so had to move indoors. In reality this is something of a plus - clearly this is a very popular pub. Noticeable how many locals from the village popped in (evening and next morning breakfast). Hard to score a pub down because it’s too popular (I’d like it to myself).

The location was excellent. We were walking The South Downs Way and found that to get there from the trail was a very pleasant woodland detour. The owners/staff were extremely welcoming and friendly and couldn't do enough for us. The breakfast was exceptional. The choice was excellent and also the quality and all options were included in the accommodation price (there were no hidden extras for the cooked options as we found at other accommodation). The room was very comfortable and tastefully decorated. It was very well stocked with different luxury coffees for a machine and also had a kettle for tea and instant coffee. Fresh milk was provided in a small fridge - not UHT! Choice of sparkling and still water bottles were also available in the room! Would highly recommend this accommodation.

Nothing.