The location was great with good coffee shops and eateries and Shelter Island all within walking distance. The room was very clean and airy. The bed was so comfortable and the toiletries provided were great too. The hotel is small and welcoming and the staff were friendly and helpful.

Sadly the restaurant is closed on Sunday and Monday nights (the 2 nights I stayed) so there was not much going on in the hotel whilst I was there - it was very quiet. I was told that it’s a great place for cocktails (when open!). It would also have been great to have some comfortable loungers by the pool rather than just upright chairs.

Great property, beautifully renovated and nice style with lots of lively details. Comfortable spaces.

Lack of iron and ironing board and coffee maker in the rooms was disappointing. I wouldn’t usually miss an iron but travelling for work sometimes requires it. I’d recommend coffee makers in the rooms.

lovely, room and furnishing, good soundproofing, comfortable mattress helpful receptionist, good, included breakfast with nice fruit, beautiful, outdoor pool and restaurant

water pressure in shower very low, even for California, bed too low to floor, road in front of hotel seemed dangerous to cross on foot or bicycle (which I did not rent) due to speeding cars. A stop sign given location of hotel in relation to harbor, would be sensible. No apparent assistance for carrying luggage up stairs

The room was very nice and the staff were extremely helpful and friendly. The hotel was also easy to reach and in walking distance of the sea.

Slightly more facilities (mini fridge in the room, breakfast in the restaurant) would have been nice, but we managed very well without

I loved the vibe that the boutique hotel created compared to how other hotels in the area looked. I also think the staff regardless of their role, made me feel wonderful as a guest. I had a front desk employee clean the pool when I went down there to swim.

I think that price wise, it can be slightly less.

The day we arrived, happy hour was all day! They had special pricing and good snacking food.

The room we had didn't have a plug for the CPAP machine i use at night. They did compensate us with knocking off the parking fee.

Elevated but not luxurious decor. Location is great, you can walk directly to the water and nearby shops.

The pricing structure could be more straightforward; the Pearl charges a $20 convenience fee for what other hotels would build into the price, e.g. wifi, coffee.

The Pearl is such a vibe! The rooms are exquisitely decorated and have all the amenities! The bar and restaurant staff were very friendly and personable! Parking was always available and the location is perfect! 10/10 would recommend!

There is nothing that we did not like about our stay here! It was absolutely fabulous and we will definitely be back at the pearl when we visit!

This property is a hidden gem! The spa vibe is amazing! Bamboo and sea grass surrounded the pool giving privacy from the street and feeling of relaxation All the products were eco friendly and the food was upscale organic 10 out of 10

N/A

I liked the room and the bed was super comfortable along with the pillows. Wish we could have taken a pillow to go 😄

I didn't like that there wasn't a fridge or something to store food and or drinks but we managed.