Breakfast was very good, but a little slow in getting our tea, the gardens and surroundings were fabulous, it's clear that the gardeners take pride in what they do. Wish the bar area was a little bigger, it would seem there is plenty of space. Staff very helpful but felt that we could have been asked on being shown to our room if we wished a kettle and tea, I think these should be in the room without having to ask.

The room was very good but decoration was a little tired. Beautiful curtains but let down by 2 very cheap looking ceiling lights.

What a beautiful place! The gardens are stunning. The food was excellent. The location for golf is awesome. All the staff are lovely.

It's not quite value for money. The attitude to cleaning could be a little more detailed, there were a lot of cobwebs. The coffee machine is an enigma! Most importantly, the water pressure is dreadful; utterly impossible to shave with hot water, and the shower was sometimes ok but never great

The main building and surroundings are lovely, with gardens you can visit and enjoy at your leisure. In our cottage, the bed was big and comfortable, and it was a good size. The location was very convenient, and the wi-fi signal on our cottage was excellent. The breakfast was also delicious and well-presented when served. The staff was friendly and accommodating to our requests while we stayed there.

The room seemed cold even though the weather was hot outside. I imagine this was because the cottage is ground-level, where sunlight doesn't shine directly on the property. There were also some signs of deterioration within the property that you wouldn't expect in a 5-star hotel.

Service and staff were excellent. Love the location. Beautiful garden.

Although it is pet friendly (paying £20 per day), dog is allowed only in room. We could not have breakfast or dinner at the restaurant, so had to other room service (different menu from their restaurant). It would be nice to have an area in the dining/drinking/library area for guests with dogs.

Beautiful small hotel - an architectural gem designed by Lutyens with Gertrude Jekyll gardens. Wonderful location in the dunes of the East Lothian coast. Discreet and competent service. Quiet and comfortable single room. Very good food.

Non-golfers should note that the other guests were golfers. Some maintenance was needed on the window catches in my room.

Whats not to like? Amazingly beautiful Lutyens property with great setting next to Muirfield golf course. I was able to book a room at 10pm on a Friday night after another hotel booking had been cancelled by mistake,elsewhere.

Minor things The bed was unfortunately too soft for my body I did not have a key

Beautiful architecture. Comfortable old world charm. Lovely restaurant - dinner and breakfast were delicious. Staff friendly and helpful. Beautiful setting overlooking the golf course

Room wasn’t serviced despite us putting the sign on the door. TV signal in the room was very poor

This hotel is just beautiful. The public areas are so peaceful with no TVs or background music. This is our ‘go to’ place when we need total relaxation. This trip we had the opportunity to dine with food prepared by Chef Michel Roux jnr and accompanied by the most perfect wines. I mean what is there not to like.

There is absolutely nothing you can’t like here.

A beautiful house with a beautiful garden!

The shower water was very hot, & not easy to make a little cooler. Funny to have this experience in UK, where almost sixty years of experience has been too little hot water in the bathrooms!

Greywalls is a fabulous reminder of days gone by. The house is full of family mementos and portraits, which make it feel homely and welcoming. Library and other public rooms with a nightcap, the fire going and the live piano was a perfect way to end the evening. Breakfast was excellent. Lovely views over Muirfield and the sea. Our Cottage room (aka the Kings Toilet - seriously, was originally a courtyard where Edward 7 would sit on the ‘throne’ as he liked open-air evacuations!) was fabulous. Spacious and very private with lovely views of the walled garden. Staff were attentive and charming.

It was clean but after all those years coujd probably go with a deep clean and possibly some re-upholstering.