Stylish , clean, lovely big comfortable beds Very nice staff Amazing cocktails

Few small issues - with food which after reporting (was room service) no one got back to us when I brought it up upon checking out the manager was happy to offer a resolution . I have eaten here before and the food was top so think this was a one off No water in the room - most places offer complimentary bottles these days

Hotel was nice and clean staff were friendly and helpful. Only problem I really had was with the heating turning it’s self up and keeps getting to hot in the room says to reception about it and man put it in cool and it stayed that way. Last thing was I didn’t have any water bottles of water in the room usually when I stay there is normally 2 bottles on the bedside tables one at each side when I asked them if the room was ment to have water in it he says no so I asked him if he could send a bottle up as I was really thirsty because of the heat in the room and it never did get sent up apart from those to miner issues the stay was great.

The heating turning its self up my water not being sent up to the room. The face there was no water to drink in the room.

The room was clean and spacious, and the bar staff were lovely and can make an excellent cocktail. Dog freindly for an extra £25 you get a dog bed and bowls and can take your pet into the bar area. It's very central, so cracking location.

The hotel looks a bit tiered lift and lobby looks like it needs a good clean. Food is way overpriced. Lobster mac&cheese was a letdown at £26. I would stay again and definitely get the cocktails, but I would eat out as I think it's just way overpriced for the quality.

The breakfast offered a huge variety of foods,which would suit most people and was very good. We enjoyed our evening meal and found the staff to be very attentive and helpful. We liked the location of the hotel. It was very central and close to all the attractions including the V and A museum.

I was disappointed that the hotel didn't have a car park or a compensatory arrangement for parking ie. We paid for parking from our arrival time up to 11.20a.m. the following day, but the hotel could compensate the guest by offering a drink on arrival or something similar to take the sting out of that.

Our dog was made welcome. Staff were helpful.

Room was a bit stuffy and too warm.

We liked the warm welcome at reception. The staff were super courteous and obviously enjoying customer engagement! We loved our large, warm, comfortable room with views over the Tay and immaculate bedding and towels. Hotel is close to train station, airport and tourist haunts. A short drive over the Tay bridge allows exploration of Fife coastal villages. Very nice! We loved dinner and next morning breakfast served by smart, knowledgeable young men and women in the large comfortable dining/breakfast room also with great views. The hotel retains some of its historical features which is really nice too.

We understood that a near future refurb will update the somewhat dark interior colours used in otherwise very modern decor.

I love Malmaison hotels wherever they are. Attention to detail in slightly quirky ways. Dinner was excellent. I was upgraded for not cost - thank you!. 'Continental' breakfast is a bit of a misnomer - compared to my stay in Prague earlier in the year.

In the dining room the tables next to the windows were all for four or more people. We singles - and there were around 8 of us - were on the other side of the room. I wonder if the hotel would consider changing the layout of the dining room so singles could sit at the window - we like to be by the light too! Also I feel the colour palette of the hotel is now a bit passé - on the gloomy side.

Great location, very close to the train station. Staff were all very nice (upgraded our room at no charge). Room a decent size. Fridge in room, which is very handy. Shower good, plenty hot water. Plug sockets next to bed.

I feel the building needs a bit of TLC and some money put back into it, to bring it back to life. Malmaison has a reputation of being a more upmarket hotel, but it was a wee bit run down in places (carpets coming up, wood facings chipped, stains on chairs). Room was a bit dark - more lights needed. Elevator was jolting.

Great size suite. Really nice bathroom with twin sinks, showers and free standing bath, very luxurious. Very large bed. We used the free drinks vouchers in lieu of daily room cleaning. Great breakfast with good selection of food.

We were told that the views from the hotel were amazing. At time of booking I requested a room at a high level for a good view which was confirmed. Unfortunately, we were given room 209 which was only on Level 2 out of seven. There was quite a lot of noise from the street below during the night. The floor between the bed and bathroom was very noisy and squeaked at every footstep.

A very comfortable room and bed. Plenty of space and storage. Shower simple and efficient.

My meal did not quite match the quality of the rest of the stay. I had a steak and was expecting a juicy, well cooked and rested piece of meat with a nice caramelisation. The restaurant makes steaks its speciality. My plate arrived only a minute or two after I'd placed my order. It was limp and lukewarm with no caramelised crust. That said it was fairly tasty juts not the quality I'd hoped for and the accompanying chips and mushrooms were nice.